I haven't put them against my bedsheets or curtains, because that would entail cleaning my room and making my bed.
#1 is Rake Me Over Yellow
#2 is Toy Poodle Yellow
# 3 is Feelin' Groovy Yellow (the original).
It's possible that these are all the same yellow, but numbers 1 and 2 seem to me to be slightly more full of yellow. The Feelin' Groovy is slightly paler, and so color-wise, I prefer the two new ones.
Rake Me Over and Toy Poodle are, of course, more expensive. I seem to have a sixth sense for choosing/wanting the expensive things.
How about a feel test? And a cat test?
These news samples are more plush. Rake Me Over is a bit too shaggy for my liking, but Toy Poodle feels pretty good. I think #2 - Toy Poodle is the favorite. But, am I crazy? Are these three samples the same yellow, just different thicknesses?